I’m not a fan of the 17th Amendment, so this is a hard topic to discuss dispassionately. For now, I don’t wish to discuss the merits of direct election of senators, but rather the process that was used to bring it about. The merits or lack thereof are a different topic, which I will deal with later.
After the Civil War, members of Congress occasionally suggested that states apply for a convention for proposing amendments, but there was little campaigning for one. I’m going to suggest that the Civil War pretty much cowed most states, even the northern ones, from asserting their rights, by sending a clear message that the federal government would put down by force any attempts at state sovereignty.
The Civil War ended the United States of America, a federation of diversity governed from the people through the states to the federal government and forced us…
View original post 2,176 more words